Are non-opioid painkillers as effective as opioids? What the research says

How to Get Off Opioids for Chronic Pain: Non-Addictive Alternatives That Work

On this page

TLDR

  • For long-term back, hip and knee arthritis pain, a 12-month JAMA trial found opioids were not better than non-opioid medicines at improving daily function.
  • People on non-opioid medicines had slightly lower pain and fewer medication side effects.
  • The CDC now says non-opioid treatments are preferred for pain lasting longer than a month.
  • Opioids still have a place in some situations, but they carry real risks and are rarely the best first choice.
  • The best results usually come from combining approaches: medicine, movement, mental health support and, when it fits, targeted procedures.

Why do so many people assume opioids work better?

Opioids are strong, and they often work well for severe short-term pain, like the first days after surgery or a serious injury. That made it easy to believe they would also be the best choice for pain that lasts months or years.

For years, opioids were widely used for chronic pain even though the evidence for long-term benefit was very limited. Most placebo-controlled trials lasted less than six weeks.  So researchers set out to test the question directly.

What did the JAMA study find?

The SPACE trial, published in JAMA in 2018, compared opioid and non-opioid medicines over 12 months in 240 adults with moderate to severe chronic back pain or hip or knee osteoarthritis pain.  Everyone already had pain despite taking some form of pain reliever.

How the study worked

One group started on immediate-release opioids such as morphine, oxycodone or hydrocodone with acetaminophen. The other group started on acetaminophen (Tylenol) or a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) such as ibuprofen or naproxen.  In both groups, doctors adjusted the medicines over time to reach each person’s pain and function goals.

Function was the same

Over the year, opioids did not do better than non-opioid medicines at improving how pain affected daily life, such as work, sleep, walking and mood. 

Pain was slightly lower without opioids

Pain intensity was modestly better in the non-opioid group across the 12 months. 

Side effects were higher with opioids

People taking opioids reported significantly more medication-related side effects.  The researchers concluded that the results do not support starting opioids for moderate to severe chronic back pain or hip or knee arthritis pain.

What the study does not tell us

The trial looked at people who were not already on long-term opioids, and it focused on back, hip and knee pain. It did not test cancer pain, end-of-life care or pain right after surgery. If you already take opioids, do not stop suddenly. Changes should be made slowly with your doctor.

What do national guidelines say now?

The CDC’s 2022 guideline for prescribing opioids states that non-opioid treatments are preferred for subacute pain (lasting one to three months) and chronic pain (lasting longer than three months). It also notes that non-opioid treatments are at least as effective as opioids for many common types of short-term pain.

The guideline does not ban opioids. It asks doctors to weigh the expected benefit against the risks for each person and to try to get the most out of non-opioid options. You can read the CDC’s summary of the recommendations for more detail.

What are the risks of each option?

No pain medicine is risk free. Knowing the tradeoffs helps you make a better decision with your doctor.

Opioids

Common side effects include constipation, nausea, drowsiness and dizziness. Over time, the body can get used to the medicine, so the same dose works less well. Opioids also carry a risk of dependence, misuse and overdose, which goes up with higher doses and when combined with sedatives like benzodiazepines.

NSAIDs

These can upset the stomach and, with regular use, raise the risk of stomach bleeding, kidney problems and heart issues in some people. Your doctor will check your health history before recommending them long term.

Acetaminophen

It is gentle on the stomach but can harm the liver at high doses or when combined with alcohol. Check labels, since it is in many cold and combination medicines.

Is medicine the only option?

No. The strongest pain plans rarely depend on one pill. Doctors call this multimodal care, which means using several treatments together so each one does part of the work.

Movement and physical therapy

Guided exercise builds strength around painful joints and the spine and is a core part of treating back and arthritis pain.

Mental health support

Long-term pain affects sleep, mood and stress, and those in turn make pain feel worse. Approaches like cognitive behavioral therapy can help break that cycle. Our behavioral health team works alongside pain care for this reason.

Other non-opioid medicines

Some antidepressants and anti-seizure medicines help certain types of nerve and widespread pain. They work differently from standard pain relievers and are prescribed based on the type of pain you have.

When do interventional treatments make sense?

When pain comes from a specific source, a targeted procedure can sometimes calm it more directly than a pill taken by mouth.

Joint pain

For arthritis in the knee, options like knee injections place medicine right where the pain starts. They are usually considered when medicine, weight management and physical therapy have not given enough relief.

Spine and nerve pain

For back and nerve pain, image-guided injections and other procedures may be options depending on the cause. The right choice depends on your exam, imaging and how your pain has responded so far.

These treatments are not a fit for everyone, and none guarantee results. A pain specialist can tell you whether your pain has a clear target that a procedure could treat.

Questions to ask your doctor

  • What is most likely causing my pain?
  • Which non-opioid options have I not tried yet?
  • What are the risks of this medicine for someone with my health history?
  • Would physical therapy or behavioral support help my pain?
  • Could an injection or other procedure fit my situation?
  • If I take opioids now, what is the plan for reviewing or reducing them?

Talk to a pain specialist in NYC

If you are weighing your options or worried about the medicines you take now, an evaluation can help you find a plan that relieves pain and keeps risks low. Our pain management team builds treatment around your diagnosis and goals. Book a visit with Maywell Health to talk it through.

In Pain? We’re Here to Help.

One click. Real answers.